What Is Cross Border Tax Compliance? A Complete Overview

Businesses and large enterprises like yours are taking India’s economy to soaring heights. And as your global trade continues to grow, your business starts operating in a complex landscape of different tax jurisdictions that can seem overwhelming to navigate. 

In this article, we’ll look at what cross border tax compliance means, the types of taxes it covers, challenges and also some best practices to help you scale your business without any penalties.

Cross-border tax compliance is an assurance that you’re following tax rules in every country where your business operates, sells or hires. It mainly covers income tax on profits, VAT/GST on sales, and payroll taxes for a global team.

This compliance is applicable to any company with cross-border activity, like Indian exporters or SaaS startups with customers in European countries. Without proper handling, your firm risks getting fined up to 200% of the tax due along with blocked refunds as highlighted in the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) guidelines on international tax rules.

Cross-border tax compliance saves you from massive penalties, double taxation, and operational disruptions, and supports your global business growth. 

Non-compliance with this tax is also considered under criminal charges by jurisdictions if you’re doing business with the EU and the USA. On the other hand, with compliance, you can unlock ‘treaty’ benefits to avoid double taxation, in which the same income you’ve earned has to face levies in multiple countries. OECD reforms have leveled the playing field by allowing countries to recover over $150 billion annually by curbing profit shifting. 

And for Indian MNCs and SaaS firms, it supports FDI inflows and market access amid GST on imports and PE rules.

Cross-border transactions cover multiple tax types based on activity location, nature of the goods or services and even the business structure. You need to identify the applicable taxes early to register, withhold and claim treaty reliefs. This saves you from surprises like unexpected VAT liabilities or customs holds. Here are the types of taxes:

• Income tax: This type of tax is levied on profits that are earned from permanent establishments or sourced income. Residence countries tax worldwide earnings, and the source countries claim the local profits under the PE rules.

• VAT/GST (Indirect taxes): At each stage of production, distribution and the sale of goods or services, consumption taxes like VAT and GST are levied.

• Withholding tax: Withholding tax is deducted right at the source on cross-border payments for dividends, interests, royalties or services. The percentage of deduction is decided by the DTAA and the treaties.

• Custom duties: These include tariffs on imported physical goods based on HS codes.

• Transfer pricing adjustments: These ensure arm’s length pricing, meaning they reflect fair market prices, for intercompany deals under OECD guidelines.

The key international tax concepts include Permanent Establishment (PE), transfer pricing, double taxation and more. These foundational ideas shape cross border tax compliance for global businesses. You can ensure fair profit gains and be well-informed to leverage treaties with a clear understanding of these key concepts:

• Permanent Establishment (PE): Here, the local tax nexus is created by fixed places of business like offices, servers or dependent agents. Also, OECD defines thresholds to determine when a large enterprise becomes liable to pay a minimum level of corporate tax.

• Transfer Pricing: Methods like CUP or TNMM are used to determine the arm’s length pricing for intercompany transactions.

• Double taxation: This is when the same income is taxed in the residence as well as the source countries.

• Source vs Resident taxation: Source taxes on local-origin income, for example, royalties, while residence taxes are on the global earnings of the taxpayer.

• Arm’s length principle: This states that transactions between related parties must mimic unrelated deals that are established in OECD guidelines and BEPS actions.

Tax treaties are also known as Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (DTAAs). They are responsible for resolving conflicts when multiple countries try to claim tax on the same income. 

DTAAs goals are to promote smoother international trade, and for that, they clarify rules on permanent establishment, residency determination, and withholding rates. Also, they enable tax authorities to exchange information and curb evasion. India maintains over 90 such treaties with important partners like the USA and Singapore.

There are multiple global frameworks that govern cross border tax compliance, such as the OECD Two-Pillar Solution, EU VAT Directive, and BEPS. And over 140 countries have adopted OECD’s reforms. They guide businesses on profit allocation, transfer pricing, and transparency to reduce disputes. Here are some frameworks for better understanding:

• OECD/G20 inclusive framework on BEPS: Here you’ll be introduced to the two-pillar solution. Pillar one performs the reallocation of digital profits to market countries, and pillar two sets a percentage of global minimum tax on your business.

• OECD transfer pricing guidelines: These guidelines implement the arm’s length principle for all intercompany deals and are considered as a cornerstone for audits and documentation across the globe.

• EU VAT directive: This directive mandates all cross border sales registration, e-invoicing and ‘One-Stop-Shop’ for simplified filings across the member states.

• Multilateral instrument (MLI): MLI modifies thousands of treaties to implement BEPS measures like anti-abuse rules and faster dispute resolution through MAP/arbitration.

• UN Model tax convention: This is helpful for developing nations as it emphasizes source-based taxation for services and royalties.

Cross border tax compliance faces challenges like including varying rules of multiple countries, permanent establishment risks, and complexities involved in a digital nexus. Here are some of the challenges that global businesses have to be vigilant about:

• Regulatory inconsistencies: VAT rates differ from one country to another. And also, the registration thresholds vary, which leads to compliance mazes for businesses.

• Permanent Establishment (PE) risks: Aspects like servers, remote employees, or agents can trigger unexpected income tax nexus that are without physical offices.

• Frequent multi-jurisdiction filings: Monthly or quarterly VAT returns in more than 20 countries can lead to overwhelming processes, and deadlines can misalign at times, on a global level.

• Documentation for transfer pricing: To prove arm’s length pricing, you require extensive and clear records, that’s a complicated demand to be fulfilled.

Digital and SaaS companies have to face different issues with respect to cross border tax compliance. This is because their revenue flows without physical goods or offices. Here, the nexus consists of user data, cloud servers, or marketplaces like AWS. India's GST treats exports as zero-rated but demands place-of-supply proof for OIDAR services.

OECD Pillar One shifts digital profits to market countries, while platforms for cross border tax compliance automate filings, rates, and e-invoicing. This keeps manual errors at bay for startups and enterprises with a global base.

Indian businesses can streamline their global operations by adopting strategies like early registrations, automation tools, and transfer pricing documentation. Here are some best practices that you can benefit from while navigating OECD rules and local nuances at the same time:

• Register and file on time for VAT/GST once you hit the thresholds. This helps you avoid retrospective penalties and blocked refunds.

• Use automation platforms for real-time tax rates, e-invoicing and multi-country returns to eliminate any manual errors from the process.

• According to the OECD methods, you must maintain arm’s length evidence along with master or local files to defend during audits.

• Perform assessments on a regular basis for servers, agents and the remote staff to avoid any income tax liabilities.

• You can also take the help of local experts or advisors to navigate through the complex markets you wish to enter.

Cross-border tax compliance is a dynamic space that bubbles with challenges as well as growth opportunities for your business. But with effective strategies like automation and expert guidance, you can ensure seamless operations right from filing to scaling in the market without any penalty fear. 

To power your payment collection across more than 140 countries, sign up with Xflow today!